The Strive mechanic from Magic the Gathering’s Journey Into Nyx set created some very interesting cards. Silence the Believers is an interesting piece of removal for Black. It’s essentially an instant-speed version of Gild, a formerly playable card which exiles a target creature for four mana. However, while it doesn’t give you the Gold “trophy” token that Gild does, Silence the Believers does have the ability to exile additional creatures for 2B each.
While this sounds pricey, the ability to exile any Auras attached to said creatures can be pretty relevant in the right competitive format. At the time it was released, Silence the Believers seemed sure to see play with the rampant use of Bestow creatures. Bestow creatures that have been played as Auras would be exiled, as well, rather than hitting the board as a creature when the enchanted creature leaves the battlefield.
At times, you’re going to two-for-one or even three-for-one your opponent with Silence the Believers. For 4 mana, that is pretty decent. The additional Strive cost is fair, as well, with 2 colorless and a Black being well worth taking out each additional creature and its Auras.
Also, since it is exiling a card, Silence the Believers is able to take care of Indestructible creatures. During the Theros block, the most popular indestructible creatures were the Gods, which are indestructible Enchantment Creatures. Most of the Gods saw play a lot. So, used correctly, Silence the Believers was a great answer to both Bestow Creatures and the Gods of Theros. In that particular metagame, it was pretty efficient removal. While the Strive cost can be pricey, in mono-black, with Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx around, it could provide a lot of potential value printed onto one card.
What Happened with Silence the Believers in Standard?
Silence the Believers did see some amount of Standard play during the time of Theros block and Khans of Tarkir block, especially after the release of Magic Origins. The most successful deck to run Silence the Believers was Esper Dragons. Even then, it wasn’t run in every Esper Dragons deck. When it was, it was mostly a sideboard card. It was also occasionally seen in the mainboards of Abzan Midrange and Blue/Black (UB) Control.
Because of the metagame, it was worth running a copy in your 75 if you were playing competitive Standard. While the Gods weren’t seeing as much Top 8 play by the time of Origins Standard, there was one creature you really wanted to see exiled: Hangarback Walker. When the Walker died, he’d leave behind a bunch of flying Thopter tokens. Exiling the Walker means no tokens get generated since no “when it dies” triggers can activate.
Additionally, Silence the Believers was good against big creatures like the Dragons of the time and Siege Rhino. Four mana to deal with any one of these threats was worth it. But, once Silence the Believers left Standard, its popularity quickly fizzled out.
Silence the Believers Long Term Value
In most constructed formats, four mana is too much to remove any one creature. Typically, three mana is the most you’ll see people want to pay, with cards such as Hero’s Downfall and Murder fitting that bill. In Modern, four mana gets you Damnation in Black. The format also has Path to Exile for a single White mana. So, there isn’t any room for Silence the Believers to succeed there. Sure, there are Aura-based Modern decks, but the primary one, Bogles, has Hexproof on most of its creatures. In the corner cases where Bogles plays a creature without hexproof, Path to Exile does the job. Also, Bestow creatures and Gods rarely see any Modern or Legacy/Vintage play.
How is Silence the Believers in EDH, though? Black is a very powerful color with plenty of mana acceleration available to it. Indeed, Silence the Believers sees a fair amount of EDH play, primarily in mono-Black decks. But, it’s hardly a staple in the format. Yes, as a card that can remove multiple creatures from play at once, it’s certainly a playable removal spell. Also, exiling creatures is much more relevant in Commander than it typically is in other formats. Most other Constructed formats usually have more efficient ways to do so.
Other than its EDH playability, there isn’t really a chance for Silence the Believers to see a major rise in demand. While I wouldn’t call Silence the Believers a good Magic “penny stock” to invest in, it can never hurt to stash a copy or two away of this bulk rare for your Commander deck building needs.